Hybrid methods for integrated aircraft routing and crew pairing problem with short flight legs

The aircraft routing and crew pairing problems are two processes that are difficult to be solved in the airline operations planning due to the rules that each flight leg needs to be operated on by one aircraft and one crew pair. These two problems, though interrelated in practice, are usually solved sequentially and often leads to suboptimal solution. Thus, this research contributes to the solution of the integrated aircraft routing and crew pairing problem in order to determine the minimum cost of this integrated problem where each flight leg is covered by one aircraft and one crew pair. This study also considers short connection between two flight legs in order to ensure that the crews do not change the aircraft if the connection time is in between 20 to 59 minutes. Another consideration is the restricted connection that imposes penalty costs when the second flight leg uses the same crew but not the same aircraft. Based on the literature review, most of the existing solutions concentrate on minimizing the planned costs. Although the minimum costs are significantly important in airline operations planning, the efficiency of a solution method in terms of computational time cannot be neglected. It is necessary to solve the integrated problem by using an efficient model that is able to generate a good high quality solution in a short time as requested by the airline industry. In order to solve the problem, a set of feasible aircraft routes and crew pairs are initially generated to be used as the input data in solving the integrated model effectively. There are two heuristic methods which are proposed in generating the set of feasible aircraft routes and crew pairs namely constructive-based heuristic and Genetic Algorithm (GA). The generated feasible aircraft routes and crew pairs are then used in solving the integrated problem by using Integer Linear Programming (ILP) method, Dantzig Wolfe Decomposition method, Benders Decomposition method and Particle Swarm. Computational results obtained from these methods are then compared by testing them on four types of aircraft with different number of flight legs based on Malaysia local flights for one week flight cycle. From the numerical results, it can be concluded that the proposed methods are more efficient compared to the ILP method available in the literature in terms of the computational time where the hybrid algorithm of GA and Benders Decomposition is found to be advantageous compared to the others. The maximum cost deviation of only 4.77% also justifies the strength of this hybrid algorithm. One possible future research that can be extended from this study would be the development of an algorithm that incorporates a parallel GA within the proposed methods for larger instances which are likely to exist in international flights in order to speed up the planning process

The Integrated Aircraft Routing and Crew Pairing Problem: ILP Based Formulations

Minimization of cost is very important in airline as great profit is an important objective for any airline system. One way to minimize the costs in airline is by developing an integrated planning process. Airline planning consists of many difficult operational decision problems including aircraft routing and crew pairing problems. These two sub-problems, though interrelated in practice, are usually solved sequentially leading to suboptimal solutions. We propose an integrated aircraft routing and crew pairing problem model, one approach to generate the feasible aircraft routes and crew pairs, followed by three approaches to solve the integrated model. The integrated aircraft routing and crew scheduling problem is to determine a minimum cost aircraft routes and crew schedules while each flight leg is covered by one aircraft and one crew. The first approach is an integer programming solution method, the second formulation is developed in a way to lend itself to be used efficiently by Dantzig Wolfe decomposition whereas the third one is formulated as a Benders decomposition method. Encouraging results are obtained when tested on four types of aircraft based on local flights in Malaysia for one week flight cycle